COMPARISON OF IGMPv1 vs IGMPv2 vs IGMPv3

IGMPv1 –

It was the first IGMP version that allowed to explicitly announce its willingness to receive particular multicast traffic. This version had two messages only:

  1. The Membership Query and

  2. Membership Reply.

The Membership Query was always sent to 224.0.0.1 by multicast routers, and the Membership Report was always sent by stations to the group that a station wanted to join.

Advertisements

There was no message to announce that a station is leaving (unsubscribing) a multicast group, resulting in situations that a multicast stream was fed to a segment even after all stations have left the particular group.

Only after a timeout period the router discovered that there are no more subscribers to the group, and stopped the multicast feed.

IGMPv2 –

The next version of IGMP among other IGMP versions had some enhancement –

  1. Membership Query was of both types i.e. general (sent to 224.0.0.1) and group-specific (sent to a particular multicast group). The general Membership Query is used to find out all multicast groups that the stations are subscribed to. The group-specific Membership Query is used to find out if there is a subscriber for a particular group.
  2. Leave a message (A new message )to advertise that a station is unsubscribing from a multicast group, allowing the router to stop an unnecessary multicast stream feed much more promptly.
  3. IGMPv2 cleared the way how a multicast querier (a router that sends Queries) is elected if there are multiple multicast routers connected to a common network. In IGMPv1, all multicast routers were expected to send Queries. The IGMPv2 stipulates that only the multicast router with the lowest IP address on the segment shall become the Querier and send Queries. Other routers are free to listen to the Replies (they have to do it anyway) but they do not send Queries themselves.

IGMPv3 –

It was introduced as a need to support source-specific multicast. The IGMPv1/IGMPv2 does not have the capability to specify a particular sender. The extensions of the IGMP to support the source-specific multicast led to the creation of the IGMPv3.

IGMPv1 vs IGMPv2 vs IGMPv3

FEATUREIGMPv1IGMPv2IGMPv3
1st Octet value for Query message
0x11
0x11
0x11
Group address for General query
0.0.0.0
0.0.0.0
0.0.0.0
Destination address for General query

224.0.0.1
224.0.0.1
224.0.0.1
Default Query Interval60 sec
125 sec125 sec
1st octet value for Report
0x12
0x16
0x22
Group address for the report
Joining multicast group address
Joining multicast group address
Joining multicast group address and source address
Is report suppression mechanism available
YesYesNo
Can max response time be configured
No , fixed at 10 sec
Yes,0 to 25.5 sec
Yes,0 to 53 min
Can a host send a leave group message
NoYesYes
Destination address for leave group message
-224.0.0.2
224.0.0.22
Can a Router send Group-specific query?
NoYesYes
Can a Host send Source and group specific reports?
NoNoYes
Can router end Source and Group specific Queries?
NoNoYes
Rule for Electing a Querier?
None (depends on multicast routing protocol)
Router with the lowest IP address on the subnet
Router with the lowest IP address on the subnet
Compatible with other Versions of IGMP?
NoYes, only with IGMP v1
Yes, with both IGMP v1 and v2

 

Download the difference table here.

 

 

 

 

 

 

For more information on IGMPv1 IGMPv2 and IGMPv3 watch this video –

Reference –

https://www.safaribooksonline.com/library/view/ccie-routing-and/9780133590890/ch07lev2sec5.html

Share this:
Advertisements

Tags:

Related Posts

About The Author

Add Comment

Social Media Auto Publish Powered By : XYZScripts.com