OSPF vs ISIS : Detailed Comparison

OSPF vs ISIS

OSPF stands for  Open Shortest Path First and IS IS stands for Intermediate System to Intermediate System.

OSPF and ISIS both are routing protocols for Internet Protocol Networks.

Advertisements

Similarities between OSPF and ISIS

Before going into the details of differences between OSPF and ISIS, let’s explore some similarities:

  • OSPF and ISIS  both are Link State Routing Protocols using the Dijkstra SPF Algorithm.
  • Both are Interior Gateway Protocols (IGP) that distribute routing information between routers belonging to a single Autonomous System (AS).
  •  Both use Hello packets to create and maintain adjacencies between the neighboring routers.
  • Both the protocols are classless protocols and support classless Inter-Domain Routing (CIDR) and Variable Subnet Length Masking (VLSM)
  • Both support Authentication Mechanism
  • Both support multipath.
  • Both support IP unnumbered links.

Related – OSPF LSA types

 

Differences between OSPF and ISIS

  • OSPF operates on the top of IP layer whereas ISIS operates over Layer 2.
  • OSPF can support virtual links but ISIS can not support (as it operates on Layer 2 directly).
  • OSPF elects a DR and BDR on broadcast networks which can not be pre-empted however, ISIS elects a single DIS which can be pre-empted.
  • IP connectivity between the routers to share the routing information is required in case of OSPF, while ISIS doesn’t require IP connectivity as the updates are sent via CLNS instead of IP.
  • OSPF is prone to attacks hence security overheads are required for protection. The possibility of attacks is very less in case of ISIS as it runs over Layer 2.
  • OSPF designates a backbone area and standard or non-backbone area for inter-area advertisements whereas ISIS organizes the domain into different levels.
  • To identify a router on the network, OSPF uses Router ID and ISIS uses System ID.
  • OSPF is less flexible with more strict requirements for forming neighbor adjacencies. The  hello and dead intervals, and the subnet mask must match  (except on point-to-point links).

Below table enumerates the differences between OSPF and ISIS protocols –

If preparing for your next interview, please go through the list of  Top 100 OSPF Interview questions.

 

Watch our related video –

OSPF MTU Mismatch – Stuck in EXTART

Share this:
Advertisements

Related Posts

About The Author

Add Comment

Social Media Auto Publish Powered By : XYZScripts.com